American author

ACOTAR (One of my favorite series of all time)

A Court of Thorns and Roses

Release Date: May 5, 2015

130,423 words / 432 pages

Spice level:

Rating:

This book, blending magic, fairytale elements, and intense romance (though the romance scenes weren’t my favorites compared to others in the series), truly deserves all the praise. I loved it! Here are five reasons why A Court of Thorns and Roses earned my 5-star rating:

Fairytale Retelling
I was initially hesitant because I’ve had mixed feelings about Beauty and the Beast retellings in the past, especially Beastly by Alex Flinn, which I didn’t enjoy. However, ACOTAR was a delightful surprise. While it’s rooted in the Beauty and the Beast story, it’s incredibly original and full of creative genius. Sarah J. Maas takes familiar elements like a curse, magic, and romance, but adds dark magic, steamy moments (and I do mean steamy!), blood, and court intrigue. It’s everything I love wrapped up in a perfect package. The twist on the original story cursed characters wearing masquerade masks instead of being transformed into household objects-is one of the many unique touches I adored. Tamlin, though a “beast,” is more of a shape-shifting fae than a monstrous creature, so he spends most of the book as a handsome, chiseled hero. Some might argue that this detracts from the Beauty and the Beast dynamic, but honestly, no one writes hot male characters like Maas, so I’m not complaining.

Genre
Although this is a fairytale retelling, it’s not a children’s book. I initially thought it was YA, but there’s a scene after the Great Rite on Fire Night that made me realize this is more New Adult than anything. The book definitely falls into New Adult territory, with content that’s much more mature than typical YA. For parents or readers who aren’t comfortable with explicit scenes, be aware-this one is more on the steamy side.

Feyre, the Protagonist
Feyre (pronounced Fay-ruh) stood out to me because she’s so different from the usual strong, invincible heroines in fantasy books. She’s human, flawed, and deeply relatable. At the start, she’s cold, stubborn, and hardened by years of poverty and hardship. But as she moves into the Spring Court and no longer has to care for her ungrateful family, we see her character evolve. She begins to rediscover happiness, paint again, and find joy in life’s small pleasures. Her growth throughout the story makes her a character you can’t help but root for.

Honorable Mentions

  *   Sarah J. Maas’ Writing: This is Maas at her best. I feel like each book she writes gets better, and ACOTAR is no exception. I love the first-person narrative here, which keeps you deeply connected to Feyre’s journey. Unlike Throne of Glass, which shifts between multiple characters, this book’s focused perspective really worked for me.
  *   The Fae World: I would love to live in Prythian, the world of the Fae. Maas paints such a vivid picture of the Spring Court, making it feel like a literal paradise. I also enjoyed the unique Fae traditions, like the Great Rite and the various seasonal celebrations. The world-building is immersive and fun, and readers will be eager to step into these magical pages.

There’s not much more I can say about A Court of Thorns and Roses -I loved it! Sarah J. Maas is a true master of her craft, and every book she writes is a treasure.

A Court of Mist and Fury

May 3, 2016

186,220 words / 640 pages

Spice level:

Rating:

A Court of Mist and Fury became one of my top books of 2016, possibly even my number one. After devouring the first book, I had been eagerly awaiting this sequel and preordered it as soon as possible. Upon receiving it, I paced myself, savoring every moment, especially knowing I’d have to wait another year for the final book. I’m a huge Sarah J. Maas fan-while I didn’t quite connect with her Throne of Glass series, this one is perfection, and Maas has truly outdone herself.

Picking up where A Court of Thorns and Roses left off, Feyre, Tamlin, and Lucien are working to restore the Spring Court, but Feyre is deeply scarred from her previous experiences. While the first book was a love story, this one is about Feyre reclaiming her self-worth after trauma. Her growth throughout the novel was remarkable-she goes from being a somewhat unlikable character to a strong, relatable heroine, the kind of role model I wish more teens had.

As you’d expect, Rhysand steps into the spotlight in this book, and he definitely rivals Tamlin (but to be so much better). Initially, I wasn’t sure who to root for, but now I’m firmly #TeamRhysand. There’s no love triangle to worry about here, which was a relief. I also found myself loving almost every character-whether they were wonderfully complex or deliciously villainous. Nesta, in particular, grew on me more than I expected, and I ended up liking her more than Elain, a shift from my feelings in the first book.

The world-building is another highlight. Unlike the first book, which was limited to the Spring Court, Under the Mountain, and the human realm, A Court of Mist and Fury takes us all over Prythian. The Night Court, especially, was a stunning surprise. Maas’ writing really brings each location to life, making me care about every single place Feyre visits. Normally, I skim descriptions, but here, I absorbed every word.

The story itself is incredible-heartbreaking, intense, and beautiful. Over 600 pages, Feyre navigates personal growth, mental conflict, complicated relationships, and the threat of war. I was worried the long length might drag, but it never did. Every moment felt necessary, and there was no filler.

The book also contains more mature content than the first, which was refreshing for me as an adult reader, but it’s worth noting for those who prefer less explicit material. That said, it adds authenticity to the story’s themes of love, war, and relationships.

Rhysand, need I say more? He is one of my top tier book boyfriends and I adore his character.

In short, I adored A Court of Mist and Fury. It’s hard to find anything negative to say-Feyre’s growth, Rhysand’s charm, the incredible world-building, and the emotional rollercoaster made it a perfect read. I’m already obsessed.

A Court of Wings and Ruin

May 2, 2017

199,464 words / 720 pages

Spice level:

Rating:

Feyre steps up as a determined fighter, ready to do whatever it takes to protect Prythian. Following her failure to damage the Cauldron in A Court of Mist and Fury, she infiltrates the Spring Court under the pretense of being brainwashed, manipulating Tamlin’s belief that her departure was Rhysand’s doing. Feyre uses this deception to dismantle Tamlin’s court from within. Meanwhile, the King of Hybern moves forward with his war plans, intent on destroying the wall and conquering all the courts. The only hope of stopping him lies in uniting the High Lords—a near-impossible task—and even that might not be enough. Salvation may come in the form of unlikely allies, ancient monsters, and Feyre, Amren, Nesta, and Elain, who are uniquely powerful as “made” beings.

This book is an emotional rollercoaster that had me in tears more times than I can count—happy tears, sad tears, and moments where the sheer emotional weight of the story was overwhelming. One scene in particular, where Rhysand rallies his friends before the final battle, gave me Lord of the Rings vibes and left me a sobbing mess. His words carried the weight of potential final goodbyes, and the foreboding atmosphere was palpable: would SJM dare to kill off a beloved character?

The pacing is significantly faster than the previous book, A Court of Mist and Fury. From Feyre’s sabotage in the Spring Court and the tense meeting of the High Lords to the intense library attack and action-packed battles, the narrative doesn’t let up for a second.

The world-building also reaches new heights as Maas ties together lingering threads while introducing more layers of depth to Prythian. Characters like the Weaver, the Bone Carver, and the library creature play crucial roles, and seeing all the High Lords gathered together, with their powers on display, was thrilling. Romance fans will be pleased with the continued development of Feyre and Rhysand’s relationship, as well as hints of future romances involving Cassian and Nesta, and possibly Elain and Lucien.

The character arcs in this book are deeply satisfying. Where the previous installment focused on Feyre’s healing, this one solidifies her transformation into a strong, independent force. Her ability to take control, make bold decisions, and accept herself is a testament to her growth. Rhysand’s unwavering trust in Feyre, even in the most dangerous situations, speaks volumes about their partnership and makes them my favorite bookish couple.

Tamlin’s journey, though more subtle and in the background, is also noteworthy. He evolves from someone who tries to possess Feyre to a man who ultimately prioritizes her happiness, redeeming himself by saving her life. While he’s still flawed, this moment of selflessness feels like a fitting conclusion to his arc.

The ending is surprising yet satisfying. Amren’s return—albeit changed—is a pleasant surprise, and Rhysand’s brief death feels like a necessary moment of resolution, cementing Tamlin’s acceptance of Feyre’s choices. Tamlin’s decision to make the final sacrifice underscores his growth and brings his story to a poignant close.

This series has cemented itself as one of my all-time favorites. It’s a perfect blend of dark fantasy, political intrigue, romance, and fierce, complex female characters. If you enjoy these themes, this is a must-read series. With novellas waiting to be explored, there’s still more to savor in this captivating world—so don’t miss out!

A Court of Frost and Starlight

May 1, 2018

57,763 words / 240 pages
Spice level:

Rating:

A Court of Frost and Starlight by Sarah J. Maas is a charming and heartwarming addition to the A Court of Thorns and Roses series. Though it lacks the intense drama of the main novels, it serves as a beautifully crafted interlude, offering fans the chance to reconnect with beloved characters in a more intimate and reflective setting.

Reading this feels like catching up with cherished friends. Set against the backdrop of the Winter Solstice, the story captures how Feyre, Rhysand, and their close-knit group are navigating life after the monumental events of the last book. The festive atmosphere adds a touch of magic and coziness, making it an ideal read for a peaceful evening.

The emotional development of the characters shines throughout. Feyre’s journey of healing through art is especially poignant and deeply moving. Rhysand remains as captivating as ever, and the unwavering connection between him and Feyre highlights the strength of their love. Supporting characters like Cassian, Nesta, and Mor also have their moments, subtly hinting at future challenges and growth that promise exciting developments ahead.

While some might see this novella as a “bridge” in the series, it fulfills an essential role, offering a reflective pause between larger plotlines while setting up intriguing possibilities for what’s next. The writing remains as lush and evocative as ever, with Maas imbuing every scene with a sense of intimacy and meaning.

For fans of the series, this novella is a must-read. It’s a delightful return to Velaris, filled with warmth, humor, and camaraderie that embody the spirit of the story’s world. More than just a book, it feels like a shared celebration with the characters we’ve grown to love. Highly recommended!

A Court of Silver Flames

February 16, 2021

210,289 words / 768 pages

Spice level:

Rating:

“A Court of Silver Flames” by Sarah J. Maas is a stunning and powerful addition to the A Court of Thorns and Roses series. It’s raw, unflinching, and dives deeper into the complexities of healing and redemption than any of its predecessors. For fans of the series, this book marks a tonal shift—far from a fairy tale, it’s a gritty tale of resilience, pain, and remarkable growth.

The story focuses on Nesta Archeron, Feyre’s older sister, and her struggle to rebuild after the life-altering events of previous installments. Known for her polarizing nature, Nesta’s perspective is an emotional journey that bares her trauma, anger, and guilt with striking authenticity. Watching her confront her inner and outer demons is both challenging and rewarding. Her transformation isn’t linear or neat, but that’s what makes it feel so real and compelling.

Cassian plays a pivotal role alongside Nesta, and Maas crafts a male lead who embodies both strength and vulnerability. His steadfast support, even during Nesta’s toughest moments, is profoundly moving. Their fiery, complex, and passionate relationship unfolds with a captivating mix of tension and tenderness, making their dynamic one of the book’s standout elements.

In addition to their story, the book enriches the ACOTAR universe with thrilling new elements. The camaraderie among Nesta, Gwyn, and Emerie during their Valkyrie training is empowering and uplifting, showcasing the strength of sisterhood and the importance of shared healing. Their bond is a bright highlight amidst the story’s heavier themes.

The narrative is both introspective and action-packed. While character development takes center stage, high-stakes drama and breathtaking world-building keep the pace engaging. Maas introduces new layers to Fae lore, alongside challenges and vivid, awe-inspiring settings that bring the story to life.

The book also tackles mature themes like grief, PTSD, and self-worth with boldness and sensitivity, offering a story that balances heartbreak with hope. It underscores the message that even the most fractured lives can be pieced back together into something beautiful.

At nearly 800 pages, the book is an immersive experience, with a deliberate pacing that pays off emotionally and plot-wise. It’s not just about Nesta’s journey but also a poignant reminder that growth, though messy and painful, is ultimately beautiful.

In summary, “A Court of Silver Flames” is a remarkable continuation of the series, blending personal transformation with a magical, expansive world. Whether you’ve admired Nesta or found her difficult to relate to, this book offers a fresh and transformative perspective. It’s a moving story of redemption and resilience—a must-read for fans of the series.

Throne Of Glass Series

Throne of Glass       

Release Date: August 2, 2012

113,655 words / 432 pages

Spice:

Rating:

Although I am aware that some individuals find Sarah J. Maas’s writing style objectionable, I truly enjoy her books. Without needing to be like “Blah blah blah,” Celaena’s writing seems to be able to portray the thoughts, feelings, and reactions of the characters in a really relevant, personal way, especially in her most recent works (Tower of Dawn, etc.). Additionally, there are several sentences that are exactly the same if you have read Maas’s previous book, A Court of Thorns and Roses. This is similar to a small fangirl easter egg search.

The fact that Celaena is a deadly assassin who is strong, cunning, and strong is one of my favorite qualities about her. Despite this, she may be snarky, girlish, feminine, and frivolous at times. I think it’s great that Sarah J. Maas created a heroine that enjoys shopping, wearing lovely gowns, and being a total badass. Indeed! Women in real life are multifaceted and have a wide range of interests at once.

Nevertheless, Celaena can irritate me at times, my goodness. Despite everything she’s been through, I try to keep in mind that the girl is only seventeen and is therefore permitted to be more than a little immature. I guess it might just be me getting older, but I have this problem with a lot of YA fantasy literature.

Celaena, however, strikes me as a really likable protagonist overall. She isn’t delicate. Certainly not one of those heroines who waits for a guy to train her or even to save her. She is terrible on her own. She also has a lot of secrets and mystery. There is a lot of intrigue because you never know what she is hiding or what she has up her sleeve.

I feel like I don’t even need to bring this up, but I can’t help myself. This book has fantastic world building. In my opinion, Sarah J. Maas is the undeniable queen of worlds. I adore both of the universes she has built, as far as I am aware. Conflict, intricacy, and history abound in the TOG universe. This book contains both a wealth of knowledge and a wealth of ignorance. SJM should write many stories set in this setting, in my opinion.

In fact, I found the “King’s Champion” plot to be one of the book’s worst elements. In fact, I found it really uninteresting. And a little unbelievable. In any case, I felt that the book’s main plot was a little weak.

In the beginning, the novel moved slowly, but it quickly accelerated. When everything was disclosed (as much as it is in this novel), I was taken aback because the twists weren’t particularly evident either. It’s undoubtedly a fantastic book, and I can appreciate its enormous fan base.

Concluding remarks

This series is developing really nicely! You will be captivated by the first book, but you must continue. It significantly improves. As I mentioned above, Throne of Glass is by far the poorest book in the series. If you enjoyed it at all, you should read the rest of the series because it gets much better.

Crown of Midnight          

Release Date: August 27, 2013

114,494 words / 448 pages

Spice:

Rating:

I didn’t have high expectations for this book after THRONE OF GLASS, but Maas has given me a delightful surprise. I gave the first one a rating of around three stars because, although it was a light and enjoyable read, I was really let down by the characters as well as by a number of crucial elements of the writing and organization. For this book, the majority of those items were remodeled and fixed, and I immediately found myself liking it more. Celaena exhibits moral ambivalence regarding her murders from the very first page and demonstrates thought for more complex ethical problems. In fact, she changes and matures during the book! Who would have guessed?

Having said that, the first half of the book is devoted to the story’s introduction part, which establishes the plot and characters. About 40% of the way through, I genuinely believed I had allowed myself to get ahead of myself and was just in for another full book of the same cheesy waltzing about significant themes that the first one had covered. However, the tale picks up steam around the halfway point and doesn’t let up.

Another thing that really pleased me about this novel was that it did not focus as much on the love triangle. Only because it served as a catalyst for the narrative events that transpired in the second half of the story—at which point romance retreated to the sidelines and gave way to action—was romance a major theme in the first half of the book. I was happy that the love element was utilized to assist and strengthen the plot rather than serve as the primary plot-draw for readers, as it was in the first novel. The story was considerably easier to read as a result.

This book also has a wealth of information on Celaena’s personal history and world history, both of which are presented in an excellent manner. Though not to the point that it leaves nothing for the following novels to address, the main narrative that one can infer will be the series’ overall focus is further developed. The main plot is actually just getting started, in my opinion.

The fact that Maas gave away every detail of Celaena’s past at once is my only worry in this respect. Although the ending was fantastic and her character had a beautiful developmental twist that would have been ideal for the last book of a trilogy, I am a little worried about where she will take the character going forward given that there are reportedly four more books or something planned. As previously stated, Celaena’s lack of depth and development in book 1 made me dislike her. Now that Maas has revealed all of the development and revelations at once, I fear that Celaena will revert to being emotionally flat and uninteresting for the remainder of the series.

But I guess that’s why she wrote it, and as a reader, I have to have faith in her to keep me astonished, taken aback, and entertained. I’ve decided to wait cautiously for the next installment and will end by stating that even anyone who, like me, felt the first book was “okay” should appreciate this sequel considerably more. Don’t base your decision to read this on the first book if this describes you. Despite having a similar beginning, it is far superior, and I am confident that you will find it far more enjoyable.

Heir of Fire 

Release Date: September 2, 2014      

163,266 words / 592 pages

Spice:

Rating:

Maas has written another excellent and captivating book. Although it wasn’t as good as her earlier works, it was still really nicely written. The novel is filled with action that is difficult to put down. Everywhere you go, there are captivating storylines with unexpected turns. In this book, both new and old relationships show good character growth. Mystery, romance, friendship, adversaries, alliances, and many other things are all present. This book leans toward maturity and is undoubtedly a bit darker. That pleased me. It provided further fodder for thought.

Having saying that, there were still several aspects I felt were missing. I will refrain from giving away any spoilers. Characters do, however, undergo some significant alterations. Some fans will probably be surprised, but I think that if they go back and read the last few chapters of book 3, it will give them a hint as to what will happen in this book. That was a bit disappointing. The shifts in Aelin’s personality were expected. That was not my kind of thing. I was more taken aback and found it more difficult to understand her prior three books. Even if I was still unable to guess some of the stories, the ties in this book were too obvious. I admire how the reforms are aimed at empowering her to rule like a queen. I still appreciate her sarcastic remarks and impetuous behavior. The idea that she was so near to the chest in this novel bothered me. Because she didn’t trust her companions, they frequently made poor decisions and got injured as a result. I’m specifically recalling a moment with her cousin. For her own punishment, Aelin continues to be a glutton. Her rage and dark side are largely to blame for what transpires. Even after things were made clear, I still felt that something was missing. In several passages, Maas’s writing seems to be forced with emotion. Although it might surprise some, her love interest in the book was blatantly clear. They have experienced horrible experiences, death, and monsters together, and he is attractive. She has a certain emotional connection to them and is attached to them in a certain way. Can you think of a girl who wouldn’t be attracted to such a man? The fact that Aelin can still be resentful and unforgiving is what I still find problematic. Is she the only one who can breach all the rules? I can understand that she is still unsure of who she is. She would most likely require at least a couple therapists if she were a real person. Aelin is fantastic. I am eagerly anticipating the next installment because I still adore this gal.

The other powerful female character in this book is Manon. Despite her intense internal battle, she ultimately appears to have found her feet. Reading about her pure willpower is delightful. In real life, I doubt we would be friends, but in a fantasy world? Yes, exactly. I think the time Maas spends developing her character in this book will be enjoyable to readers. She is still trying to figure out how to reconcile her strong views regarding humans, witches, demons, her family, her heritage, and her life. She makes a good clan heir. Her camaraderie, leadership, and friendship with the thirteen are still growing.

Take it out. Well, another old friend has returned. That not everything from Aelin’s house is gone makes me happy. It contributes to giving her court and her people hope. She is clever, kind, resourceful, cunning, strong, and a fighter. Although she would not acknowledge all of these attributes herself, she does exhibit them. She will be helpful in giving Aelin powerful allies down the road. Her presence is something I hope to see more of soon.

All right, so to sum up, it was amazing, thrilling, fast-paced, fun, impossible to put down, full of highs and lows, and a success. Why, therefore, only four stars rather than five? primarily because I have some major storyline problems. This book seemed to be more of a conclusion. Some of the story’s plot points are uninteresting, and some of the characters weren’t well developed. As a fan and reader, I think that’s a good explanation. She did, however, continue to provide entertainment and a realistic whole. I was tense and eager to finish because of her. That, in my opinion, is success. Simply said, the entire five wasn’t worth it. Currently, this review does not mention all of the people. There should, in my opinion, be some mystery remaining; else, why read? In addition, those have already been discovered by others. Does purchasing the book make sense? Indeed. Despite my own disappointment, will I keep reading the series? Indeed. I think there will be more changes in the next two novels. I look forward to more.

Queen of Shadows           

Release Date: September 1, 2015      

183,840 words/ 672 pages

Spice:

Rating:

It has already received many 5-star reviews on other platforms, and although I think this series is a 5-star read overall, I was a little let down by this one; it was a decent book, but not a fantastic one, in my opinion. In the end, I gave this book a 4-star rating. Both the author’s writing and my interest in this series are to blame for my inability to put it down. Additionally, I really liked some of the scenes despite my overall disappointment. I had really high expectations for this book because I genuinely enjoyed and related to all of the characters. Overall, I really like this series and would highly suggest it to anybody, although this installment will not be among the novels I reread.

Empire of Storms   

Release Date: September 6, 2016    

195,332 words / 720 pages

Spice:

Rating:

I enjoyed every bit of the action in this novel. Things in this novel never felt particularly slow, though I do think they became a little monotonous after a while. Nevertheless, there was always something going on, and it was EXCITING.

I adore every single one of the strong, amazing women in this book. They’re all fierce combatants. I adore the way they keep the boys guessing.

The romance in this book didn’t appeal to me, though I suppose it’s partly because I’m always disappointed that Chaol wasn’t the focus of Aelin’s love. In overall, I think I’m liking Rowan more and more. I dislike him with Aelin, but I no longer HATE him.

Every single person in this book was a lustful adolescent! And I soon realized how old it was! Aelin and Rowan were kissing, scratching, and biting at every turn.

It’s unbelievable that I’m stating that all I wanted was for them to keep it in their pants.

It would not have changed anything, in my opinion, if a significant portion of this book had been omitted. I find repetition to be really annoying when reading, and this book had a lot of it. I don’t want to ever again read the phrases “baldly,” “incarnate,” or “limn” in any manner.

As a whole:

This was a lot of fun. It was a fantastic book full of strong and magnificent women and fantastic relationships, despite the repetitiveness, annoying lustiness, and overwritten parts. I just needed to hold the last book yesterday since the ending kind really hurt.

Tower of Dawn        

Release Date: September 5, 2017

191,282 words / 688 pages       

Spice:

Rating:

This brief Tower of Dawn review contains no spoilers. I rate this book 4.5 stars. While reading this novel, I was reminded of Sarah J. Maas’s heyday. The plot and writing style were comparable to her early works, which are, in my opinion, her best works. These include the Assassin’s Blade novellas and the first two books in this series. I was instantly transported to this other country by her writing, complete with fascinating people and a rich cultural heritage. Who am I joking with? It didn’t hurt that it’s about Chaol, my favorite character from Throne of Glass.

Maas’s strength is her capacity to build upon the groundwork she established in the past. Long before their utility is made clear and their purpose is fully realized, she presents personalities and gives clues. We first encountered Yrene Towers in the second Assassin’s Blade novella, and we had no idea that she would go on to play a significant role. I never imagined that the messages concealed in Celaena’s palace bedroom’s tapestry had not yet been made public. These are just the first two that come to mind, and it is so much fun to see how these puzzle pieces fit together as the story progresses. Everything is a single, amazing jigsaw puzzle.

The characters—even the new ones—make it a page-turner right from the start. This novel alone has as much world-building as some whole YA series. Additionally, the climactic drama, the connections to earlier series volumes, and the spoilers for the finale are all very amazing.

Will book seven have 2,000 pages? How can Maas ensure that every character she has developed and every plot point that needs to be resolved receives the proper amount of page time? I’m eager to watch her do it! Does anyone else believe that the last installment will see the deaths of a few important characters? It would be unrealistic if all of the main characters lived because there is such a large ensemble. I’ve made a guess as to who might fail. Do you? If so, kindly let us know in the comments! Additionally, if they include spoilers, kindly mark them. There is a spoiler in my prediction, but if anyone is interested, I’ll post it in the comments section below.

One final warning: The tone is not YA-appropriate, as appears to be the case with Maas’s most recent works. The language and the circumstances in Tower of Dawn are not appropriate for young readers, even though it is cleaner than her previous books!

Kingdom of Ash

Release Date: October 23, 2018 

272,682 words / 992 pages

Spice:

Rating:

It was a long book. To be honest, it was probably lengthier than it had to be. At first, I didn’t agree with what some individuals had said. Even at page 600 or so, I was more than happy to savor these people and the separate plotlines that contributed to such a spectacular conclusion for as long it lasted.

However, I wasn’t very thrilled with some of the happenings in the book, which was between 770 and 800 pages long. With all of the anticipation for the ultimate “showdown” and the Wyrdgate’s closure, I was disappointed in how everything turned out. It felt like over all things just didn’t go the way I expected and wanted it to go. So, in my opinion not the best in the series and had a disappointing ending, but overall I think the series ended on a 4.5-5 star overall.